Reviews

Best Rat Poison Reviews: Complete Guide

Are you looking for the best rat poison to rid your home of these pests? Then take a look at our complete guide to the best options with all the Pros & Cons
Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

According to news reports across the country, America has a rat problem. Research shows that cities like New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago have massive rat populations that are starting to cause problems for residents.

Rats carry a multitude of diseases, and they often transmit them to humans. For example, San Francisco is currently dealing with the emergence of typhus; a third-world disease wiped out in the United States for decades.

However, the cities rat population is growing at a rapid rate and the fleas that feed on rats carrying typhus end up feeding on the homeless population around the city. As a result, what was thought to be a medieval disease no longer in existence, is making a comeback.

Typhus is one example of a dangerous disease carried by rats. However, in most cases, doctors can cure patients suffering from the effects of the disease. However, rats can carry fatal diseases like the “bubonic plague,” which has a far higher mortality rate than typhus.

There’s a saying that goes, “if you see one rat, there are 100-more in the local area that you can’t see. If you notice rats rummaging through your garbage can, or feeding in your vegetable garden, then it’s time for you to take action against these vermin.

Using rat poison to kill vermin infestations is a prudent and effective way of controlling rat populations around your property. However, there are different brands or poison products available, and how do you know which one to buy?

You might have young children or pets that could accidentally eat the poison, and possibly end up dying. We put together this review of the best rat poisons to give you an idea of the options available.

Top Picks for the Best Rat Poison

You might not have the time to read through our entire review. Fortunately, we made things easier for you by placing our top three recommendations for the best rat poison in this section for easy reference. Choose the product that matches your needs, and get rid of the rats plaguing your property.

Top Pick: MOTOMCO Tomcat Mouse and Rat Pack Killer

MOTOMCO Tomcat Mouse and Rat Pack/Pail, 3-Ounce, 22 Count Pail
  • Tougher than a barnyard cat for controlling rats and mice
  • Kills rats and mice in 4-6 days
  • Size: 3 Ounce

For the most effective rat poison, we recommend MOTOMCO Tomcat Mouse and Rat Pack Killer. This poison works through the rats repeatedly feeding on the bait.

It’s a pet-friendly option, and suitable for use inside or outside the home. This formulation kills rats and mice in four to six days, depending on the size and species of the rats.

Runner Up: Farnam Just One Bite II Bait Pellet

Farnam Just One Bite II 1.5-Ounce Pellet Packs, 86 Count
  • Death is delayed 4 to 5 days, so there's no bait shyness
  • Kills warfarin resistant Norway rats
  • Norway rats, roof rats and house mice may consume a lethal dose in a single night's feeding

This poison kills rats with one feeding. It’s the best choice for use in agriculture, and this poison will keep your barn free of rodents. The poison comes in pellet format and is available in an 8-lbs box.

Best Budget Pick: D-Con Corner Fit Mouse Poison Bait Station

D-Con Corner Fit Mouse Poison Bait Station with 1 Trap and 20 Bait Refills
  • This is our safest bait station, and is resistant to tampering by children & dogs
  • Compact design & low profile bait station helps reduce house mice problems
  • Weather-resistant, and can be used indoors or outdoors
  • Can be used in tight places around the house
  • Ideal for: attics, behind appliances, basements, garages and sheds

For those homeowners looking for affordable and effective rat poison, we recommend the D-Con Corner Fit Mouse Poison Bait Station. This station is tamper-resistant and safe for use around children and pets.

The Best Rat Poison Reviews

Now that you have our top choices for rat poison products in this review, let’s take a deep dive into the rest of the best rat poisons and give you the information you need to make an informed purchase decision.

If you’re having trouble with selecting the right rat poison for your application, then read through our buyer’s guide for more information.

MOTOMCO Tomcat Mouse and Rat Pack Killer

If you have rats, then you need a fast and effective solution for getting rid of the rodents in your life. The MOTOMCO Tomcat Mouse and Rat Pack Killer offer you an efficient and affordable means of ridding the rats from your property.

This poison comes in a standard pellet format, with food-grade ingredients. The portion size is ideal for rats, ensuring maximum absorption of the poison in the rat’s system. In most cases, the pellets kill rats in 4 to 6-days. However, larger rat species, such as Norway rats, may require multiple feedings for the poison to be effective.

This product is a standard rat poison formulation, meaning that you’ll need to clean up rat corpses immediately, as a pet or wild animal feeding on the rat could cause cross-contamination and poison the animal.

The MOTOMCO Tomcat Mouse and Rat Pack Killer is a straightforward poison that produces excellent results and its cost-efficient as well.

Pros:
  • Kills rodents in less than 6-days.
  • Comes pellet format.
  • Food-grade ingredients.
Cons:
  • No immediate kill.

View Details

Farnam Just One Bite II Bait Pellet

For those people living on farms or smallholdings, by the time you realize you have rats, there are dozens of them skulking around your property. Rats get into the vegetable garden and destroy crops, they rummage in the barn and leave droppings everywhere, and if you don’t kill them, they’ll continue breeding and multiplying quickly.

Fortunately, Farnam Just One Bite II Bait Pellet is a specialized formula for agricultural use. This potent rat poison contains anticoagulant that causes rapid death in rats after only one feeding. The rats typically last 3 to 4-days before dying.

The pellets feature nibble edges to encourage feeding and feature central holes for use on bait stations. It’s important to note that this product is not suitable for use around the home. The potent toxins in this formulation cause cross-contamination, harming pets, and local wildlife if the animals eat the dead rat corpses.

Farnam Just One Bite II Bait Pellet is all you need for the ideal agricultural rat solution. This bait gets rid of rats fast, ensuring they don’t overrun your property. This formulation is effective on all breeds, including Norway rats.

Pros:
  • Suitable for agricultural usage.
  • Kills rats with one feeding.
  • Comes in a bulk 8-lb box.
  • Suitable for killing Norway rats.
  • Designed to promote feeding.
Cons:
  • Not available in residential doses.

View Details

D-Con Corner Fit Mouse Poison Bait Station

If you need an effective way to kill rats around the home or an apartment, try the D Con Corner Fit Mouse Poison Bait Station. This compact rat bait station features a secure design, and your pets or children cannot get at the bait. The station comes with 20-bait refills, which is enough to get rid of the largest rat colony.

The ingredients in the formulation of this product are non-toxic to humans. You don’t have to worry about any cross-contamination to your pets or local wildlife.

The D Con Corner Fit Mouse Poison Bait Station offers a safer rat solution using pellets, and it’s suitable for use around the home or in an apartment.

Pros:
  • Tamper resistant and safe around children and pets.
  • Designed as a bait station.
  • Suitable for use indoors and outdoors.
  • Safe formulation.
Cons:
  • May not be effective at killing Norway rats.

View Details

Neogen Rodenticide Ramik Nuggets

Neogen Rodenticide Ramik Nuggets are a versatile rat poison that kills rats, mice, and voles. If you have a vegetable garden where voles and rats are getting out of control and eating your crops, then this is the best rat poison for your situation.

The pellets come in a large portion size that’s suitable for a once-off feeding that kills the vermin in your garden. These pellets are water-resistant, and they won’t melt away like other pellets if they get wet.

This specially formulated rat poison for damp or wet climates is the ideal choice if it rains frequently in your area. The poison wont dissolve, and you get an effective rat killer that solves your rat [problem around the home.

Pros:
  • Suitable for exterminating rats, mice and voles.
  • Suitable for use indoors and outdoors.
  • Formulation id wax-free.
  • Suitable for use in wet and damp conditions.
Cons:
  • Not suitable for killing Norway rats.

View Details

JT Eaton Rodenticide Anticoagulant Bait

This poison comes in bait blocks that are slightly larger than your average pellet size. You get 144-blocks per 9-lb container, making this poison the ideal choice for landlords looking to clear large rodent populations form commercial buildings.

The rat poison features anticoagulant formulation, causing internal bleeding and death in rats in as little as 48-hours. However, you’ll need to properly dispose of the corpses before they cause cross-contamination with other animals in the area.

We wouldn’t recommend this poison for use around the home, especially if you have pets or children, or there’s plenty of local wildlife in your area.

JT Eaton Rodenticide Anticoagulant Bait Blocks attract rats with its pleasant peanut-butter fragrance. They’re an effective anticoagulant poison that causes death in rats in as little as 2-days after ingestion.

Pros:
  • Available in a 9-lb bulk pail.
  • It has a peanut butter flavor.
  • Anticoagulant properties.
  • Suitable for mice and smaller rodents
  • Block bait system.
Cons:
  • Not suitable for killing Norway rats.

View Details

Pest Control Rat Traps from Kat Sense

The Pest Control Rat Traps from Kat Sense comes in a six-pack, and offer homeowners an effective means of catching rats and smaller mice in the home. Unlike other trap systems that break the rat’s skin, causing blood to mess over the immediate area, these rat traps offer a humane trapping system.

The body of the trap features construction with polystyrene, with an integrated bait cup at the bottom of the base of the trap. The killing arm snaps shut, instantly ending the rat’s life, but without breaking its skin.

Most spring rat traps cause a mess and don’t offer a humane trapping system that sometimes leaves the rat alive. The Pest Control Rat Traps by Kat Sense provides an effective kill, without drawing blood from the rat.

Pros:
  • Humane rat trap.
  • Pet-friendly.
  • Sanitary and reusable.
  • Comes in a 6-pack of traps.
  • Bait-cup design.
Cons:
  • Not suitable for killing Norway rats or voles.

View Details

Tomcat Rodent Station

The Tomcat Rodent Station offers you a safe and effective way of getting rid of rats in your home or apartment. Listening to rats jump around in the rafter of tour home while you’re trying to sleep is annoying.

The Tomcat Rodent Station offers a full body that allows you to insert a trap or bait into the station. However, the station has a long entrance with a design that only rats can enter. After the trap kills the rat, there no way your pets or children can get into the body to remove the rat.

This station is the ideal pet and child-friendly rat bait station for use in the home. The design of the body ensures that nothing but a rat can access the trap or bait.

Pros:
  • Suitable for use outdoors and indoors.
  • User-friendly set up.
  • Safe for children and pet-friendly.
  • Compact and compatible with snap traps.
Cons:
  • Not effective at killing Norway rats.

View Details

Rat Zapper Ultra Rodent Trap

If you’re looking for the most humane, effective, and efficient rat trap on the market, it’s the Rat Zapper Ultra Rodent Trap. This electric trap shocks the rat with a high-voltage charge after it enters the trap to feed on the bait.

The inventors of the Rat Zapper realize that some people don’t want the hassle of loading bait stations.

They also understand that there are people that might be squeamish about disposing of a rat’s body or even seeing a dead rat. The no-view disposal offers a way for these people to remove the rat from their home, without handling or looking at the corpse.

This electric model rat trap is an excellent solution to kill rats and keep them out of the home. The body of the machine contains the rat for no-view disposal, as well.

Pros:
  • Kills rats humanely.
  • Suitable for Norway rats.
  • 60-kills per battery charge.
  • No poison.
  • No view, no touch disposal.
Cons:
  • Not as effective as a bait station.

View Details

EcoClear Products RatX All-Natural Rat Poison

The EcoClear Products RatX All Natural Rat Poison offers you the best solution for getting rid of rats if you’re a pet owner or you live in an area with birds of prey. This formulation contains no dangerous neurotoxins or anticoagulants, and if your pet eats it, they won’t die or get deathly sick.

However, this rat poison is not effective at killing voles and some hardy species of rodents, like Norway rats. The digestive systems of these vermin resist the all-natural poison, and they might survive.

With EcoClear Products RatX All Natural Rat Poison, you remove the risk of cross-contamination in pets and local wildlife if they feed on the rat corpse before you can clear it. The non-toxic formulation contains no harmful anticoagulants or neurotoxins.

Pros:
  • Kills rats with a single feeding.
  • Pet-friendly and child-proof.
  • Biodegradable.
  • No contamination risk for vegetable crops.
Cons:
  • Not suitable for use indoors.

View Details

Rat Poison and Your Pets

Pet contamination is one of the biggest concerns for homeowners when using rat poison. The last thing you want to happen is for your dog to find that tasty peanut-butter flavor rat poison and start wolfing it down in delight. The chances are that poisoning your pets is not what you had in mind when purchasing your rat killer.

If you own pets, or you have young children, then it’s best to use a rat poison formulation that requires multiple feedings to become active. Some brands have products that steadily build toxin levels in the rat’s bloodstream as they feed on the poison bait over a few days.

Eventually, the poison levels reach a critical threshold, and the rat’s internal organs start to shut down. Therefore, this extended killing action makes these types of poisons suitable for use around the yard, even if you have pets.

If your dog eats pellets with a pet-friendly formula, they won’t eat enough of the bait to cause them to die. At worst, they might have a runny tummy for a day or two. While no-one wants to see their dog sick, it’s better than rushing them off to the emergency room at the vet.

If you have pets or you live in areas where birds of prey may swoop down on poisoned rats, then a pet-safe formulation is a musty. Killing a bald eagle that feeds on a poisoned rat would be a travesty.

Rat poison bait
Rat poison bait

Health and Safety Precautions

When handling rat poison, it’s essential to have respect for the product. Rat poison can kill you or make you deathly ill if you accidentally consume some of the bait. Handling rat poison and then eating food with your hands could end up in you poisoning yourself.

Always wear rubber gloves when handling rat poison, and after you’re done setting the bait, wash your hands thoroughly to remove any possible traces of poison from your hands. It’s also important to follow safety procedures when clearing your property of dead rats as well. Dead rats require removal, or they’ll end up rotting away, causing a terrible smell while inviting disease onto the property.

Place dead rats into a plastic garbage bag and seal it before dumping it into your trash can outdoors. It should be common sense that you wouldn’t toss dead rats into your trash can indoors.

Handling Rat Poison
Be careful when handling rat poison

How Does Rat Poison Kill Rats?

Different companies and brands offer different rat poison formulations. Some of the common ingredients found in rat poison products include; bromethalin, zinc phosphide, calcium releasers, and anticoagulants.

All of these three toxins have different mechanisms for working in a rat’s system. Bromethalin interacts with the rodents at a cellular level, affecting the mitochondria, causing a shutdown of the vital organs in the rodent’s body.

Zinc phosphide is a common toxin found in agricultural rodent killers. This toxin causes changes in the rat’s digestive system, resulting in the swelling of the internal organs and eventual death through the gas build-up.

Calcium releasers work by releasing additional calcium steadily into the rat’s bloodstream, calcifying the arteries and cardiovascular system of the rodent, causing death.

This toxin is safe for use around pets and children, and it’s one of the more popular lethal strategies for killing rats around your property. Calcium releasers won’t be harmful to pets or birds or prey that decide to feed on dead rat carcasses.

The last toxin found in some rat poisons is anticoagulant. This product causes internal bleeding in the rat after they eat the bait, resulting in a slow and painful death. You should avoid using anticoagulants wherever possible, as this toxin has a broad spectrum, and can kill a variety of animals, such as predators, pets, and birds.

However, anticoagulants may be the only option when it comes to killing toxin-resistant rats, such as the Norway rat species. These rats have some resistance against non-toxic ingredients and require a stronger poison to kill-off populations.

How long Does It Take Rat Poison to Kill Rats?

Kill times vary depending on the species of rat and the type of rat poison you’re using as bait. If you purchase rat poison and leave the box in your garage for a year, the poison becomes less active, and it might take longer for it to kill rats, or the rats might not respond to the toxins.

In most cases, rat poison takes two to three days to kill the rodent, provided that it consumed enough of the poison for it to stay active in the rat’s bloodstream and gut. Most rat poisons require repeated feeding by the rodents for the poison to reach toxic levels in the blood and gut of the rats.

As a result, the rat may take longer to die if they are feeding on multiple sources that don’t include the rat poison. However, this makes the formulation safe for your pets, as they require repeated feedings to sustain poison levels at sufficient levels. If your dog does eat the poison, it might not even display any signs of poisoning. However, the size of the pet also plays a role, and if your poodle eats the poison, it will feel the effects more than if a St. Bernard decides to feed on the poison pellets.

There are a few strategies you can use to ensure that the rats on your property consume as much of the poison bait as possible. We recommend that you look for rat runs – tiny pathways the rats run along to reach food sources.

Check around your trash cans for evidence of rats, and place the poison on the way to the food source. By putting the poison on the rat run, the rat encounters the toxin before the food source and feeds on the bait instead of the trash.

Always place the bait in the same place, as rats are habitual feeders, and return to the same food source day after day. If you spread the poison around many locations on your property, the rats may avoid it and choose to feed on other food sources in your yard or home instead.

Conclusion

By now, you should have a complete understanding of rat poisons and how they work. Choose one of the products in this review, and start baiting your rat runs. If you’re still struggling to identify the rat poison that’s the right choice for your property and home, then you can rely on our top picks in this review for an effective product that works.

If you have animals around your home, or you live in an area that has local wildlife, such as deer and eagles, then buy a product that does not cause secondary poisoning in animals that consume poisoned rats.

The needs of farmers and homeowners are entirely different, and farmers might require a stronger-acting poison that kills rats after a single feeding. Whatever your requirements, make sure that you respect the product and keep it out of sight of children and pets.

28,934 views
Robin Watson

Robin owns his own Landscape Gardening company based in the UK and has over 10 years professional experience working outdoors, creating beautiful landscapes for his clients in the UK. He is also a keen garden-grower and maintains his own fruit and vegetable gardens. He also has a level 3 Certificate in Practical Horticulture from The Royal Horticultural Society and is currently working on his first book about gardening. Contact him at Robin@gardenbeast.com

Write A Comment